Has John Galt Left The Building And Taken The Workers?

Anyone who read Ayn Rand's classic Atlas Shrugged will recognize the name John Galt. Throughout the book (and films if you watched them), the line is "who is John Galt?".

The meaning behind this was a mythical character who was hijacking the nation's leading industrialists. They were the people who ran the companies that manufactured the engines, built the bridges, and operated the railroads (it was written in the 1950s). It was based upon Rand's ideology that collectivism is bad. Here was a way she emphasized how economies run by politicians, think tanks, and "experts" was doomed to fail.

Obviously, we can sense class warfare in Rand's tone. She was against the Marxist mindset, having been born in Russia in the early 20th century (before the Soviet Union).

There is little doubt the United States has witnessed its own form of class warfare. The industrialists that Rand wrote about certainly are targeted. However, that is not the John Galt class. Instead, we might be looking at something Rand hypothesized occurring, yet in a way unimagined to her.

For those who did not read the book, John Galt was able to convince the leading industrialists to walk away from their companies. As they were attacked with accusations of profiteering, pushed to endured endless regulation, and to try to conduct business as spelled out by politicians and bureaucrats (an impossibility), they simply walked away.

Naturally, we can imagine, with that type of "brain drain", society started to fall apart. Infrastructure literally started to collapse as bridges fell, the trains stopped running, and a host of other industries vital to the ongoing survival of society imploded.

Are we see this play out today?

image.png
Source

The Blue Collar Worker

In the United States, college is something that is pushed upon everyone. If you do a search of "college scam" you will see how, for the most part, young people are saddled with huge debt loads to spend 4 years receiving worthless degrees. The upper level education system in the US is committing highway robbery, indebting students for life.

For some, it is a path to a brighter future. When people major in fields such as science, engineering, accounting, and information technology, they can usually find jobs on the higher end of the pay scale. To these people, money spent on their education was an investment.

As for the rest, it is an albatross around the neck. It makes you wonder why someone would think that spending all that money on an ancient Irish poetry degree would really amount to much. Does someone really think that history is a major that is going to be in high demand? The same goes for art, theater, and sociology. While there might be a few who break through, most are not going to make it in that area.

But this is what society promotes. The challenge is that, when it comes down to it, society doesn't truly need these things. As for the knowledge, much of it is available if one simply knows how to use Google.

What is interesting, and where the Ayn Rand-John Galt theory comes in, is the fact that people from the crucial jobs are disappearing. In the U.S., we are finding a deficit of welders, plumbers, and electricians. We are seeing blue collar fields such as automotive having a tough time finding people. I was talking to a neighbor who made an appointment for an oil change in his car: 3 weeks. That is how long it took to get it in.

This is an oil change we are talking about. Thirty years ago there was a quick change oil shop on near every corner. Now, it is weeks to get the vehicle in.

The reality is that, as the education system pushes people into college, ensuring they rack up debt in return for a piece of paper that has a 80% chance of being worthless, less people are entering these crucial fields to keep the basics of society running.

Who is John Galt and where have all the average workers gone? Perhaps that is the question.

All Chiefs, No Indians

There is a saying about too many chiefs and not enough Indians. This means that we have a lot of people who want to be running the show yet few willing to engage in professions that actually contribute. The engines of society, those laborers who keep the basics running simply are disappearing. At the same time, these are also fields that are very difficult to automate.

What happens in another decade when we have millions of more people with degrees in human gender relations and fewer plumbers? That will not bode well when the pipes break. But hey, we will have a full slate of political science majors who can tell us all we need to know about why political party X or politician Y is treasonous for the country.

Someone once asked me if I was counseling a high school student, what field would I suggest to enter? Thinking about this is not easy since it has to be something that will not change over the next couple decades. With technology advancing, we can easily see many industries are going to be disrupted. What is ironic, in a world of algorithms, white collars jobs are highly at risk. They might not have figured out how to eliminate the field yet, but it could happen. Give developers with increasingly more powerful neural networks a number of years and do not be surprised if they zap many of the office jobs we see today.

So what would my suggestion be to a 17 or 18 year old? Welding.

A number of years ago, I knew a guy who was a welder for the gas company. He is the type who is willing to work hard but wants to be left alone. There is no management aspirations in this guy whatsoever. He is good at what he does, knows what needs to be done, and is willing to do it. Show him the pipe, turn off the gas, and he will take care of the problem.

For this, he was paid $52 per hour up to 40 plus travel expenses. Anything after that saw the rate increase.

Ayn Rand wrote about a hypothetical situation where the leaders of many industries suddenly left. Perhaps she was wrong in her assessment yet right about the outcome.

Could we be seeing the downfall of the developed world simply because those who are capable of its upkeep and maintenance are suddenly disappearing. As the older tradespeople drift away, who is going to step in their place? What will all those sociologists and middle school history teachers do when the electrical or plumbing fails?

What will any of us do?

Certainly Wall Street has no solution for this. All the money in the world doesn't help if there is nobody there to fix (or install) the A/C.

This could be an interesting thought experiment. What happens if countries find they do not have the workers to enter these crucial fields? Will this cause a setback in the standard of living?

As someone who just met Ira, I can tell you that life without electricity, even for a few days, is a return to a time past. Imagine what would happen if trying to run a factory like that.

What are your thoughts on this subject?


If you found this article informative, please give an upvote and rehive.

gif by @doze

screen_vision2025_1.png

logo by @st8z

Posted Using LeoFinance Beta



0
0
0.000
12 comments
avatar

pixresteemer_incognito_angel_mini.png
Bang, I did it again... I just rehived your post!
Week 126 of my contest just started...you can now check the winners of the previous week!
!BEER
3

0
0
0.000
avatar

This post has been manually curated by @bhattg from Indiaunited community. Join us on our Discord Server.

Do you know that you can earn a passive income by delegating your Leo power to @india-leo account? We share 100 % of the curation rewards with the delegators.

Please contribute to the community by upvoting this comment and posts made by @indiaunited.

0
0
0.000
avatar

Excellent point of discussion. I did not read the books. I did see the movie(s) and could see many parallels with modern times. Innovation being hijacked by bureaucracy which tied the hands of inventors and company leaders.

From my understanding (which is surface level at best) the solution many countries have used over the years is to bring in workers from other parts of the world. Workers who may not live in a place where they can thrive.

Regarding Blue Collar Workers

One person I've listened to and watched is Mike Rowe. He created a scholarship program (Mike Rowe Works Foundation) to encourage more high school students to look at the trades. Trade skills pay rather well and while some go to college and accrue debt, trade skills workers are going through paid apprenticeships. Earning while learning and getting paid rather well once they are working full time.

Only time will tell whether Ayn Rand (or you) are right.

0
0
0.000
avatar

That is true, immigration was used to traditionally fill different roles. However, we are going to be confronted with a situation where developed nations are facing demographic issues so there will be a lot more competition for those workers.

Also, as the economies of the underdeveloped world advance, we will likely see the same trend away from the trades in those countries. So what happens if we see a similar fallout there?

Posted Using LeoFinance Beta

0
0
0.000
avatar
(Edited)

The situation is the same in Turkey.

The perception that university graduates are elite continues to be influential. Are they elite because they went to university? Mainly because they stand out from the rest. In the past, a small part of the population studied at university. As the number increased, the quality decreased.

0
0
0.000
avatar

Funny how it works that way. When most are allowed in, the "elite" is diminished.

I said for years, not everyone belongs in university. Today, in the West, due to the lack of qualified tradespeople, they are likely to end up elite.

If one can performs basic plumbing tasks, I imagine he or she will be in demand.

Posted Using LeoFinance Beta

0
0
0.000
avatar

Everyone needs to do an oil change and do some home relations when the pipe breaks. As you say, white-collar jobs are more at risk to be automated by sophisticated algorithms.

0
0
0.000
avatar

At the time Rand wrote the novel made sense.

Things have changed. Blue collar or white collar doesn't matter

Will be no job a robot can not do

Posted Using LeoFinance Beta

0
0
0.000
avatar
(Edited)

The jobs of the future will be increasingly different. The truth, from my point of view, there is no need to worry because it seems that nobody wants to deal with the toughest minor trades (such as plumbing, masonry, painting, brasswork, electricity, etc.), because there will always be people who are prepared and people who are not; and it is precisely for this reason that there will always be labor for jobs that require more physical effort.

Certainly, when we look at the figures and the facts, we see that more and more people are joining the study of careers, and even of subjects that are not in great demand in the real world; but that is precisely where the key to interpretation is in all of this. Because, in my opinion, when those people who studied careers that are not in demand in the real world realize that they cannot live working with what they studied, they will have to learn trades for which they did not qualify (through courses, and other means), and with it, they will have to dedicate themselves to jobs that nobody wants to do today.

Many caciques and few Indians, it is certainly the dynamic that it seems that we will have in the future, but I think that even the activities that today seem more difficult to imagine automated (because of logistics, what they mean and the unions), will be automated and robotized in the future. Apparently in the strict sense, all careers and jobs will be in danger of extinction in the future for ordinary mortals, because what will be clear is that overcoming and carrying out jobs and activities will require a lot of effort high degree of competition and specialization.

And by a high degree of competence, experience and specialization I do not mean simply having papers that prove that we study such a career, and such specialization, but that the professionals of the future will have to demonstrate their level of competence and productivity far beyond of what today can be done, because there will be such a shortage of jobs that there will be no place for people who only believe that studying anything and in any way already has the right to a salary and a stable job that pays them a salary.

Again, this is all my point of view. Thanks for sharing such an interesting article. Greetings.

Posted Using LeoFinance Beta

0
0
0.000
avatar

On a related tangent, I was watching a video in which they discuss that what we are seeing with Russia and Saudi Arabia is a demonstration of who actually has power. Western countries, such as USA and the Eurozone, believe that finance is power. Russia and the Saudis are demonstrating that commodities are power.

Russians may not be able to export as much grain through sanctions. But, they won't starve. And, with all their natural gas, they won't freeze.

The Saudis may only have petroleum to export. But, it's an export any number of countries will buy. And, they can lower production to increase profits.

Europe may have massive financial markets. But, they can't eat Eurodollars.

Which brings us back to your post. These geniuses running financial markets feel all powerful. But, in reality, they're just middlemen. Without the imported commodities they rely on to live, they aren't so powerful. In this case, the commodity producers are John Galts quitting.

China is also in the same boat. The geniuses at the CCP are dependent on outside commodities for their power. Fortunately for them, Russia is willing to trade.

Something they all share in common is an inflated sense of control over reality. They believe they can shape and bend reality to their whims. That is until reality slaps them on the head. We see this with many modern college graduates, who consider themselves as a part of that class of people who run the world, at least until their student loans come due.

Posted Using LeoFinance Beta

0
0
0.000